Beyond Right and Wrong

EVIDENCE.- Prior Research on Attorney-Litigant Decision Making.- A Current Assessment of Attorney-Litigant Decision Making In Adjudicated Cases.- CAUSES.- Psychological Attributes of Decision Errors.- Institutional Impediments to Effective Legal Decision Making.- CONSEQUENCES.- Legal Malpractice Liability For Settlement Counseling and Decision Errors.- Ethical Implications of Attorney-Client Counseling and Decision Making.- SOLUTIONS.- Obstacles to Becoming an Expert Decision Maker.- Personal Expertise in Legal Decision Making.- Group Expertise In Legal Decision Making.- Peer Review, Client Evaluations and Law Firm Audits.- Conclusion.

Randall Kiser is the principal analyst at DecisionSet®, a decision services and professional development company in Palo Alto, California. Mr. Kiser, a decision analyst and an attorney, has worked closely with litigants, insurers and attorneys in assessing risks, evaluating litigation alternatives and improving individual and organizational decision-making skills. He is the author of How Leading Lawyers Think (Springer, 2011) and the lead author of the widely read article, "Let's Not Make A Deal: An Empirical Study Of Decision Making In Unsuccessful Settlement Negotiations" (Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, Vol. 5, No. 3, September 2008). Mr. Kiser received his law degree in 1978 from the University of California, Berkeley (Boalt Hall), and obtained his undergraduate degree in 1975 from the University of California, Davis (Highest Honors). His legal education is complemented by the award in 2002 of a certificate in leadership from the Peter F. Drucker Graduate School of Management, Claremont Graduate University.

From the book reviews:

"Multiple research studies show that litigators are human and, as such, are subject to a whole host of biases and pressures imposed on them by their roles as advocates, client managers and strategists. A thick volume by Randall Kiser called "Beyond Right and Wrong" provides a great review of many of these studies and ... would be an interesting read for many litigators and litigation managers." (Galina Davidoff and Wendy L. Hufford, thelegalintelligencer.com, January, 2015)

"In the book, Mr. Kiser discusses various factors that might contribute to the poor quality of lawyers' decisions. ... it's worth noting that the book is very well-written. Mr. Kiser has all of the statistical data and a command of the math, but has presented the topic in a very readable and entertaining style." (Stephen Cavanagh, Amazon.com, November, 2011)

"A book aimed at lawyers and law students to help them see the problem of bad decision making and learn ways to improveit. ... It should be of interest for professional responsibility as well as trial practice and alternative dispute resolution." (Mary Whisner, Trial Ad (and other) Notes, trialadnotes.blogspot.de, June, 2010)

"... this tome should be near at hand in the office of every lawyer engaged in predicting litigation outcomes.... Anyone with sufficient interest in this subject, particularly attorneys, should buy the book and keep it, if not on their night-stands, at least on their desks." (Negotiationlawblog.com, February, 2010)

"This is an important book. ... Everyone associated with litigation--lawyers, business executives, law professors--should read this book. ... it provides a useful summary of the results of 35 years of research by psychologists and economists in the judgment and decision making field ... . Beyond Right and Wrong will make its way as professors adopt it for use in law and business school courses and as corporate legal departments discover its